Mar 17, 2026

JooHyeon Heo

Quantum catalysts are specialized resources that enable quantum state transformations previously thought impossible, holding promise for advancements in quantum computing and thermodynamics. A recent international study has identified the conditions under which these catalysts can operate reliably even amid environmental noise, marking a significant step toward practical quantum technologies.

Professor Seok Hyung Lie and his research team in the Department of Physics at UNIST, in collaboration with researchers from Nanyang Technological University (NTU) in Singapore, have mathematically demonstrated that most existing quantum catalyst schemes are highly sensitive to even minimal noise, leading to gradual degradation and limiting their reusability. In contrast, they showed that the catalytic channel approach uniquely maintains catalyst stability in real-world, noisy environments.

Quantum catalysts facilitate transformations between states that are otherwise impossible, akin to chemical catalysts that enable reactions without being consumed. They are expected to improve the efficiency of quantum operations and are central to developments in quantum computing and thermodynamics.

However, the study reveals that many theoretical models assume idealized conditions—precise preparation of input states—that are unrealistic outside laboratory settings. Under such assumptions, catalysts tend to deteriorate even with tiny amounts of noise, undermining their potential for repeated use.

To address this challenge, the team proposed the concept of catalytic channels—a quantum operation designed to restore the catalyst to its original state regardless of the input. Unlike conventional catalysts that require perfect state preparation, catalytic channels are inherently robust against small errors, making them more suitable for practical, noisy environments.

Their findings also demonstrated a fundamental no-go result for achieving additional benefits through catalytic channels in the presence of environmental noise. Specifically, they established that for key quantum resources—such as entanglement and coherence—even catalytic channels cannot generate new advantages under noisy conditions. This clearly defines the limits of what noise-resilient catalysis can achieve. Conversely, under certain thermodynamic conditions, stable catalytic effects remain feasible, opening promising avenues for practical applications.

“This work offers a realistic perspective on what quantum catalysts can accomplish in noisy settings,” explains Professor Lie. “It emphasizes the importance of designing structures that are inherently resilient to environmental disturbances—crucial for optimizing quantum circuits and developing microscopic heat engines, such as quantum heat engines, at atomic scales.”

Published in the 2026 February issue of Physical Review Letters, this study was conducted in collaboration with Dr. Nelly H. Y. Ng and Dr. Jeongrak Son at NUT, along with researchers from Aix-Marseille University, France, and Nagoya University, Japan. It was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) and the Institute for Information & Communications Technology Planning & Evaluation (IITP).

Journal Reference

Jeongrak Son, Ray Ganardi, Shintaro Minagawa, et al., “Catalytic Channels Are the Only Noise-Robust Catalytic Processes,” Phys. Rev. Lett., (2026).

Abstract

Catalysis refers to the possibility of enabling otherwise inaccessible quantum state transitions by supplying an auxiliary system, provided that the auxiliary is returned to its initial state at the end of the protocol. We show that previous studies on catalysis are largely impractical, because even small errors in the system’s initial state can irreversibly degrade the catalyst. To overcome this limitation, we introduce “robust catalytic transformations” and explore the fundamental extent of their capabilities. We demonstrate that robust catalysis is closely tied to the property of resource broadcasting. In particular, in completely resource nongenerating theories, robust catalysis is possible if and only if resource broadcasting is possible. We develop a no-go theorem under a set of general axioms, demonstrating that robust catalysis is unattainable for a broad class of quantum resource theories. However, surprisingly, we also identify thermodynamical scenarios where maximal robust catalytic advantage can be achieved. Our approach clarifies the practical prospects of catalytic advantage for a wide range of quantum resources, including entanglement, coherence, thermodynamics, nonstabilizerness, and imaginarity.